Our Work

Broken Promises Increase Despair
Opposition Green Caucus
October 23, 2020

By Trish Altass, Official Opposition Health and Wellness Critic

It should come as no surprise to anyone, especially anyone in public office, that mental health and addictions is a serious issue on PEI. Our office has heard countless heartbreaking stories of individuals who are struggling. Even more upsetting is the lack of help they often receive when they cry out for help. This was an issue long before COVID-19, but unfortunately, like many things, the pandemic has made it worse.

I know the current government is aware of this issue. One of their most talked about and popular campaign promises was to replace the current Hillsborough Hospital with a state of the art “Mental Health Campus.” While on the campaign trail, before he became Premier, Dennis King said he would “put shovels in the ground on day one if elected.” How exciting!

A Cruel Failure

Based upon past experience, many are not surprised when elected officials do not come through on their campaign promises. These broken promises often lead to feelings of cynicism. However, ill thought out promises that play at the people’s emotions and morals do more than create doubt, they lead to despair.

Not a week goes by that I don’t hear from someone asking when those shovels are going to hit the ground, when help is coming, when their friend, spouse, child, or loved one is going to finally have access to help they need. 

The promise of increased supports for those struggling with mental health and addictions was one they took seriously. Islanders are loving and caring people. They want all Islanders to be happy and safe and to receive the help they deserve. The failure to keep this promise is especially cruel.

A Ministry of Silence

It has been over a year and a half that this government has held office. I have reached out countless times to our Minister of Health asking him for timelines and details, trying to find out anything I could about this government’s plan to help those in need.

Unfortunately, as I am writing today, there are still no plans for the New Mental Health Campus that have been approved and shared with the public. And, there is no evidence of long-term planning to address mental health service capacity across all areas of PEI.

What I do have, however, is a track record of questionable actions they have taken. These actions do not signify respect or understanding of the seriousness of mental health and addictions crisis on PEI. 

A Record of Insensitivity

First, after they were elected as government, the shiny plans of “shovels in the ground” grew eerily quiet. For about a year, opposition asked time and time again about the new Hillsborough Hospital plans and were told vague responses along the lines of “we’re working on it”.

Then the pandemic hit. Experts around the globe were warning of the seriousness of COVID-19 and, in general, PEI has done a good job of keeping us safe from the virus. However, just behind those warnings were other warnings from experts telling us that lockdowns, fear and anxiety, job loss, etc. could cause a “shadow pandemic” of mental health and addiction cases.

Our Health Minister knew about these warnings. I even warned him myself in the House back in the Spring. So, what did our government decide to do with these warnings?

  1. Government closed almost all acute mental health and addictions services on PEI. Unit 9, the transition unit, and most in-person counseling were closed early in the pandemic.
  2. Government shuttered the liquor stores. People who are in the grip of an addiction (especially to alcohol) can not just stop cold turkey with no support. Added to this was the trigger of increased stress of living in a global pandemic.
  3. Government moved patients who would normally be admitted to Unit 9 to the Hillsborough hospital. For a personal account of how that worked for some individuals I’d suggest you read this CBC article “P.E.I. man resorts to drastic measures to get mental health help” – https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/prince-edward-island/pei-mental-health-peace-of-mind-hospital-admission-1.5769186.
    • There have been several reports on how the current Hillsborough Hospital is unsafe and unfit for housing patients. That is exactly why we are replacing it!
  4. Government publicly proclaimed our frontline medical staff were “heros”, but from what I have heard from nurses, staff, and their unions, government took little to no tangible action to recognize their struggles and sacrifices over the past six months. 
    • PEI has a severe nursing shortage, especially in mental health and addictions. Even before the pandemic began, Unit 9 could often not operate at full capacity because of staff shortages.
    • Government needs to take the health and mental health of our medical staff seriously. They need to be treated with dignity and respect. Recruitment and retention efforts depend on this.

Mental health is health. These are not the actions of a government that values mental health and addictions care. These are the actions of a government that considers mental health care as optional. 

Enough is Enough

I have had enough, Islanders have had enough. The Liberals were in government for 12 years and had no marked success in helping Islanders struggling with mental health and addictions. Our current PC government promised to be different. So far, they are no better. In fact it may even be worse.

It is time for a government that values all Islanders and takes their mental health seriously. It is time for mental illness to get the same priority as any other illness. It is infuriating that our government is making decisions that reflect an old way of thinking. If you believe Islanders deserve care for their mental health, that Islanders with addictions deserve dignity, respect, and support then please join me in calling on this government to act now!

Premier King, Minister Aylward, we implore you to take a stand, take action, and make changes. It is past time for you to finally come through for those who trusted in you.

We will not give up

To Islanders who are struggling, we hear you and we see you. Your Official Opposition continues to work tirelessly with and for you. We will not stop pressing government until we see every Islander receive the help they deserve and need.

The Opposition Green Caucus of Prince Edward Island provides a crucial role in the governing of our province. The caucus is made up of Green Party MLAs elected by Islanders.

We strive to offer informed and intelligent debate and proposals that are evidence-based and data-informed. Through respect and integrity, we seek to improve the work and efforts of government on behalf of all Islanders.

Get Updates from Us

Sign up for email updates on our work in the PEI legislature and upcoming events.

Office of the Third Party
4th Floor, Coles Building
175 Richmond Street, Charlottetown
Prince Edward Island, Canada